HPHT vs. CVD | Which Lab-Grown Diamond Growth Method to Choose?
HPHT = High Pressure & High Temperature
CVD = Chemical Vapor Deposition
Lab-grown diamonds are cultivated in laboratories using two growth methods - HPHT and CVD. In this article, we won’t focus directly on the growth methods themselves, but rather on what should matter to you as a customer when choosing a lab-grown diamond and why. This is our subjective opinion based on our experience.
CVD Method
We recommend choosing the CVD method for smaller stones that are not certified (IGI, GIA). Lab-grown diamonds produced using the CVD growth method are detected as "diamond" on testers, while small HPHT stones are detected as "moissanite." It can then be challenging to prove whether the stones are moissanites (SiC - silicon carbide) or lab-grown diamonds. The set stone would have to be removed from the jewelry, which is, of course, an unwanted intervention that could destroy the already made piece.
On the other hand, it is essential to be cautious and request confirmation from sellers of natural diamonds that the set diamonds are not lab-grown. Lab-grown diamonds are indistinguishable from natural ones, and if they are already set in jewelry, the customer has no way to differentiate them. You can’t tell the difference between natural and lab-grown diamonds even when they’re not set in jewelry, so it relies on the manufacturer’s trustworthiness regarding the diamonds they use. The only difference between small natural and lab-grown diamonds is the price. Small natural diamonds do not have certification or markings on the girdle, which all larger certified lab-grown diamonds have.
HPHT Method
For larger certified lab-grown diamonds, on the other hand, we recommend choosing the HPHT growth method. From our perspective, these are lab-grown diamonds that achieve higher quality compared to lab-grown diamonds produced by the CVD method. CVD lab-grown diamonds often achieve a lower color grade (G-H) and are then "enhanced" by using the HPHT method by one or two grades – a G-H lab-grown diamond produced by the CVD method can be improved to a higher color grade through the HPHT process. Additionally, HPHT is a method that closely mimics the conditions under which natural diamonds form deep underground. However, what can be confusing is that lab-grown diamonds produced using the HPHT method can be detected as "Moissanite" on testers. This is due to the presence of tiny metallic particles that affect the testers. On the other hand, these lab-grown diamonds have a unique number on the girdle that matches the certificate number you receive with the lab-grown diamond. Customers can then quickly and easily verify information about the color, clarity, cut, and other properties either directly from the certificate or on the IGI website (Verify Your Report - IGI). Here, you can also download the certificate in PDF format at any time.
The certificate also states whether the stone may contain additional treatments (in the case of the CVD method) or that it contains no additional treatments (HPHT). This information is listed at the bottom under the basic information about the lab-grown diamond.
Summary:
- For small uncertified stones, we recommend the CVD method.
- For larger certified stones, we recommend HPHT lab-grown diamonds.
History
The Fascinating History of Lab-Grown Diamonds
Laboratory-grown diamonds, also known as synthetic diamonds, have a rich and intriguing history that spans over a century. The journey began in the 19th century with early scientific experiments aimed at replicating the conditions under which natural diamonds form. However, it wasn't until the 1950s that significant progress was made with the development of the first commercially viable method for producing synthetic diamonds using high-pressure, high-temperature (HPHT) techniques. This breakthrough involved mimicking the natural conditions of high pressure and high temperature that create diamonds deep within the Earth. These early synthetic diamonds were primarily used for industrial applications due to their exceptional hardness and durability.
Despite these early successes, it took several decades for synthetic diamonds to become a significant part of the gem market. It wasn't until the 1980s and 1990s that advancements in technology allowed for the production of gem-quality synthetic diamonds. During this period, chemical vapor deposition (CVD) emerged as another method for growing diamonds. CVD involves breaking down gas molecules to deposit carbon atoms onto a substrate, forming a diamond. This method allows for greater control over the diamond’s properties, such as color and clarity.
Initially, the jewelry industry viewed synthetic diamonds with skepticism, fearing they would undermine the market for natural diamonds. However, as the quality of lab-grown diamonds improved, they gained acceptance among consumers who were seeking ethical and sustainable alternatives. Lab-grown diamonds are often marketed as an eco-friendly choice because they avoid the environmental and ethical issues associated with diamond mining.
By the early 2000s, synthetic diamonds began appearing in mainstream jewelry stores. Even traditional diamond companies entered the synthetic diamond market with their own products. To ensure consumer confidence, gemological institutes and other grading labs developed standards to evaluate and certify lab-grown diamonds.
Today, lab-grown diamonds are available in a wide range of sizes, shapes, and colors, rivaling natural diamonds in quality. They are typically priced lower than natural diamonds, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers. As technology continues to advance, the production of lab-grown diamonds is becoming more efficient and cost-effective.
The future of lab-grown diamonds looks promising, with increasing consumer awareness and demand driving innovation in the industry. These diamonds offer a compelling blend of beauty, affordability, and ethical appeal, positioning them as a significant player in the global diamond market. As the technology behind lab-grown diamonds continues to evolve, their role in the jewelry industry is set to expand even further, making them a popular choice for future generations.
Detailed Comparison of HPHT and CVD Diamond Production Methods
High-Pressure High-Temperature (HPHT) Method
Process Overview:
- Seed Diamond Placement: Begins with a small diamond seed.
- Graphite and Catalyst Mixture: Uses graphite and a metal catalyst (iron, nickel, or cobalt).
- High Pressure and Temperature: Exposes the mixture to pressures around 5-6 GPa and temperatures of 1,300 to 1,600 degrees Celsius.
- Diamond Growth: Graphite dissolves into the catalyst and precipitates onto the diamond seed, forming a larger diamond.
- Cooling and Extraction: Reduces temperature and pressure gradually before extracting the diamond.
Advantages:
- Color Quality: HPHT can produce diamonds with excellent color grades, including colorless diamonds that do not require additional treatments.
- Speed: Typically faster at producing large, high-quality diamonds.
- Durability: Often results in diamonds with fewer internal stresses.
Disadvantages:
- Inclusions: May introduce metallic inclusions from the catalyst, which can affect clarity.
- Cost: Equipment and operational costs can be higher due to the extreme conditions required.
Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) Method
Process Overview:
- Growth Chamber: Utilizes a sealed chamber filled with methane and hydrogen gases.
- Substrate Placement: Involves a substrate, usually a thin diamond slice.
- Gas Activation: Uses microwave energy to create a plasma, breaking down methane molecules.
- Diamond Growth: Carbon atoms deposit onto the substrate, layer by layer, forming the diamond.
- Control Over Conditions: Allows precise control over gas composition, temperature (800 to 1200 degrees Celsius), and pressure.
- Completion and Extraction: Stops the process once the desired diamond thickness is achieved, then extracts the diamond.
Advantages:
- Purity: Typically results in diamonds with high purity and fewer inclusions, as it avoids metal catalysts.
- Control: Allows better control over the diamond’s properties, such as color and clarity.
- Cost-Effectiveness: Generally more cost-effective for producing large, high-quality diamonds.
- Scalability: Can produce large, flat diamond plates that are useful in various industrial applications.
Disadvantages:
- Color Enhancement: CVD diamonds often require post-growth HPHT treatments to improve their color, as they can have a brownish tint initially.
- Growth Rate: The growth rate can be slower compared to HPHT, especially for larger diamonds.
- Stress: Can result in diamonds with more internal stresses, which may affect durability.
Certification and Grading:
Lab-grown diamonds undergo thorough evaluation and grading by leading gemological laboratories such as the GIA or IGI. These organizations assess the diamond's 4Cs: carat weight, color, clarity, and cut, issuing certificates detailing these characteristics.
The grading process for lab-grown diamonds mirrors that used for natural diamonds, ensuring accuracy and transparency in assessing their quality and value.
Price Comparison with a natural diamond:
Lab-grown diamonds offer a significant price advantage compared to natural diamonds, often costing 90% or more less. Despite being chemically, physically, and optically identical to natural diamonds, lab-grown diamonds are much more affordable. This affordability is largely due to the controlled production processes and the lack of mining costs. Natural diamonds, on the other hand, involve extensive mining, sorting, and distribution expenses, driving up their prices.
The price disparity allows consumers to purchase larger or higher-quality lab-grown diamonds for the same budget they would allocate for a smaller natural diamond. Additionally, lab-grown diamonds are free from the ethical concerns associated with some natural diamond mining practices. As technology advances, the production efficiency of lab-grown diamonds continues to improve, further driving down costs.
Despite the price difference, lab-grown diamonds retain the same brilliance and durability as natural diamonds. They are graded using the same standards and criteria, ensuring comparable quality. Many consumers appreciate the opportunity to invest in environmentally sustainable and ethically produced gems without compromising on beauty.
The significant cost savings also make lab-grown diamonds an attractive option for various jewelry pieces, from engagement rings to everyday wear. Retailers increasingly offer lab-grown diamonds, reflecting growing consumer demand. This trend highlights a shift in the market, where value and ethics play an important role in purchasing decisions.
In summary, lab-grown diamonds provide a cost-effective, ethical, and high-quality alternative to natural diamonds, appealing to a broad range of consumers.
Cut Options:
Cut Options and Colors for Laboratory Diamonds
Popular Diamond Cuts
Lab-grown diamonds can be crafted into various popular cuts, just like natural diamonds. The most popular diamond cuts include:
- Round Brilliant: Known for its exceptional sparkle, the round brilliant cut is the most popular and widely chosen diamond shape.
- Princess: This square or rectangular cut offers a modern look with plenty of sparkle, second in popularity to the round cut.
- Cushion: Featuring rounded corners and larger facets, the cushion cut has a soft, romantic appearance.
- Emerald: Recognized for its long, rectangular facets, the emerald cut highlights the diamond's clarity and elegance.
- Asscher: Similar to the emerald cut but square, the Asscher cut has a distinctive, vintage appeal with step facets.
- Marquise: This elongated cut with pointed ends maximizes carat weight and gives the illusion of greater size.
- Oval: Combining the brilliance of the round cut with an elongated shape, the oval cut is both elegant and flattering.
- Pear: Resembling a teardrop, the pear cut offers a unique blend of the round and marquise shapes.
- Radiant: With its trimmed corners and brilliant cut facets, the radiant cut combines the sparkle of the round and the shape of the emerald.
- Heart: Symbolizing love, the heart cut is a romantic and distinctive choice.
Available Colors for Lab-Grown Diamonds
Lab-grown diamonds can be produced in a variety of colors, some of which are rare and expensive in natural diamonds. The most common colors include:
- Colorless (D-F): The highest quality diamonds, completely devoid of color.
- Near Colorless (G-J): Slight traces of color that are often undetectable to the untrained eye.
- Faint Color (K-M): Slightly noticeable color, often appearing warm.
- Yellow: Varying from light to intense shades, yellow lab-grown diamonds are popular and more affordable than their natural counterparts.
- Blue: Achieved by adding trace amounts of boron during the growth process, resulting in stunning blue hues.
- Pink: Created by specific conditions during growth, pink lab-grown diamonds range from light to intense pink.
- Green: Produced by exposing diamonds to specific treatments, green diamonds are rare and striking.
- Orange: Rare and vibrant, orange lab-grown diamonds are eye-catching and unique.
- Red: Extremely rare, red lab-grown diamonds are among the most unique and sought after.
- Purple: Created by adding specific elements or treatments, purple diamonds offer a unique and elegant option.
Lab-grown diamonds offer the same diversity in cuts and colors as natural diamonds, providing consumers with a wide range of choices to suit their personal preferences and style.
Properties:
Lab-grown diamonds exhibit virtually identical physical, chemical, and optical properties to natural diamonds. They are equally hard, durable, and refractive, making them indistinguishable from natural diamonds to the naked eye. However, lab-grown diamonds offer additional advantages such as ethical considerations, as they are produced sustainably without the environmental and social impact associated with diamond mining.
In conclusion, lab-grown diamonds represent a sustainable and responsible choice in fine jewelry, offering consumers unparalleled beauty, quality, and value. With their affordability, ethical sourcing, and customizable options, lab-grown diamonds are revolutionizing the diamond industry and empowering consumers to make informed and conscious purchasing decisions.